Welcome to Online Ordering!

Sugar Cookie Options

At The Handcrafted Cookie Co, we offer a variety of custom sugar cookies that are sure to delight your taste buds. From beautifully decorated treats for special occasions to everyday favourites, we have something for everyone.

  • Personalized sugar cookies for birthdays, weddings, and more
  • Seasonal designs for holidays like Christmas, Halloween, and Valentine's Day
  • Custom shapes and colors to match your theme
  • Available in multiple flavors: our beloved classic vanilla sugar, chocolate, chocolate chip, peppermint, strawberry, mint chocolate chip, gingerbread (seasonal flavor) and pumpkin spice (seasonal flavor)

Cookie Cake Options

Indulge in our scrumptious chocolate chip cookie cakes that are perfect for any celebration. Made with the same love and care as our cookies, these cakes are sure to be a hit at your next gathering.

  • Custom designs for birthdays, anniversaries, and special events
  • Personalized messages and decorations
  • Available in various sizes to suit your needs
  • Chocolate and Vanilla buttercream options


6in round cakes serve 2-6 people $12

9in round cakes serve 8-12 people $28

12in round cakes serve 12-16 people $37

13x9in cakes serve 12-16 people $37

Number/letter cakes (2 layered, serves 10-15 per digit) $60 per digit/letter

 

  • Add a custom design (a border and message is included in cost above) for an extra $5! 

Frosted Wonderland: A Christmas Decorating Class

🎄Frosted Wonderland: A Christmas Cookie Decorating Class! 🍪

Join me for a cozy and creative evening of cookie decorating at Angel Scoops Ice Creamery & Cafe on Friday, December 12th from 6–7:30 PM!

We’ll be decorating four festive cookies:
A gingerbread house, a cozy mug of cocoa, a peppermint swirl, and a cookie tray straight from Mrs. Claus' kitchen! I’ll guide you step-by-step through each design, sharing tips and tricks to make your cookies look as magical as they taste.

🎁 Add-on option: Want to bring the fun home? DIY cookie kits will also be available so you can keep the decorating going (or gift some holiday cheer!).

✨ Only 15 spots available: so grab your seat early before they’re gone!
Perfect for a girls’ night out, family activity, or festive date night.

📍 Angel Scoops Ice Creamery & Cafe
🗓 Friday, December 12 | 6:00 PM–7:30 PM
🎟️ Tickets are $40 per person and include all supplies, a special cookie with your name (decorated by me!), and my favorite sugar cookie recipe!

Christmas Sale 2025 🎄🎅🏼

 

🎄 Christmas Sale is HERE! 🎄

Holiday treats are officially live, and I’m so excited to help make your season a little sweeter!

 

Whether you’re looking for a fun family activity or delicious goodies to share (or keep for yourself 😉), I’ve got you covered.

 

✨ DIY Cookie Kits

Perfect for kids, holiday parties, or cozy nights in!

• Kit of 4 cookies – $12

• Kit of 8 cookies – $22

Need a larger kit? Just send me a DM!

 

🍪 Cookie Variety Packs

A mix of festive favorites:

• Chocolate Peppermint

• Hot Chocolate

• Cookie Cake Cups

• Pack of 9 – $24

• Pack of 15 – $38

 

📍 Pick-Up in Lyman on Dec. 22 & 23

🗓️ Ordering closes December 15th — be sure to snag yours before they’re gone!

 

Thank you so much for supporting my small business this holiday season. I can’t wait to bake for you! 🎁✨

Ready to place your order?

Choose your favorite sugar cookies or cookie cake and let us create something special just for you!